Talking about comic books, TV shows, movies, sports, and the numerous other pastimes that make us Gentlemen of Leisure.

Thursday, March 16, 2017

X-amining X-Force #16

November 1992

In a Nutshell
X-Force battles X-Factor & and the X-Men.

Writer: Fabian Nicieza
Penciler: Greg Capullo
Inker: Harry Candelario
Letterer: Chris Eliopolous
Colorist: Joe Rosas
Editor: Bob Harras
Editor-in-Chief: Tom DeFalco

In Texas, X-Force engages the combined X-Factor/X-Men Blue team. They hold their own for awhile, but are eventually overwhelmed, and Cannonball orders them to retreat and regroup, as Wolverine sets off in pursuit. Meanwhile, the Gold team & Quicksilver arrive at a warehouse where Cerebro has located Caliban's energy signature. Inside, they are attacked by Caliban & Famine, and in the process of defeating them, trigger a message from Mr. Sinister, which says that Apocalypse is both the cause of their current situation, and a means to an end. At the X-Mansion, Sinister himself quickly overpowers Bishop, and gives Val Cooper the name of the true culprit behind the attack on Xavier. Meanwhile, Cable prepares to find Stryfe, while the captive Cyclops & Jean Grey are brought before the villain. Back in Texas, Wolverine catches up to X-Force, with the rest of his team close behind. With X-Force surrounded and overpowered, Wolfsbane begs Cannonball to stand down, and he reluctantly does, after which X-Force is taken into custody.

Firsts and Other Notables
This issue ends with X-Force defeated and in the custody of the X-Men/X-Factor, effectively ending their existence as the outlaw X-team (at least amongst the other X-teams). Going forward, they'll remain on the edges of lawfulness (even relative to the X-Men), but will do so with more implicit (and at times, explicit) support from Professor X, leading up to a time in which X-Force will actually operate out of the X-mansion, right alongside the X-Men, post-"Age of Apocalypse".

The final main villain of this story is formally introduced in this issue as Stryfe appears in it in his full Stryfe-y regalia for the first time, while Mr. Sinister makes the heroes aware that it was Stryfe, not Cable, whom attempted to kill Xavier.

In perhaps the earliest bit of foreshadowing of the later Rictor/Shatterstar relationship, Rictor and Wolfsbane are reluctant to fight one another, until Shatterstar is injured, prompting Rictor to join the fray. Likely just a coincidence at the time (it could have been any one of his teammates taking a hit that motivated Rictor), it nevertheless reads as foreshadowing in hindsight.

Mr. Sinister says that Apocalypse is responsible for what's happening, another nod at Cable/Stryfe's origin as Cyclop's son (as Apocalypse was responsible for infecting Nathan Christopher, thus forcing him to go into the future to be healed).

Another more overt hint comes when Stryfe refers to the captive Cyclops & Jean Grey as "father and mother".

Cable receives the trading card treatment for this issue.

A Work in Progress
Shatterstar refers to Wolverine as "Lord Wolverine".

Madrox & Siryn share a moment together, with Siryn referencing Fallen Angels and Madrox referencing the recent "the Madrox who was in Fallen Angels was a rogue dupe" retcon.

Icemand & Storm combine their powers, with Storm generating moisture and Iceman then freezing it, the sort of thing we really haven't seen often enough during the Blue/Gold era (ie teammates who haven't shared a lot of time together on-panel interacting and using their powers in tandem).

For whatever reason, War is not amongst the Horsemen the X-Men fight this issue.

The gaping hole in Archangel's wing has healed since X-Factor #84.

Cable returns to his Swiss safe house, seen in his limited series, to gear up.

There's another one of those unspoken creepy moments that pop up in superhero comics fairly regularly here, as Cyclops and Jean Grey, who were captured wearing civilian clothes, are presented to Stryfe in their costumes. So, did Sinister and/or the MLF undress and dress them?

The Grim 'n' Gritty 90s
Bishop blasts a hole in Mr. Sinister's head, to no avail, a la the T-1000 from Terminator 2, and this really marks the beginning of Sinister's depiction as having a malleable, largely invulnerable body.

Cable's gear as he sets out after Stryfe is laughably 90s.

Austin's Analysis
As the first act of "X-Cutioner's Song" comes to a close, two important things happen. First, Stryfe makes his full first appearance in the story (obviously, we'll soon find out he was there in chapter one shooting Xavier, but this represents his first appearance in full regalia), rounding out the triad of "major" villains for this story, with Stryfe eventually revealed as the central villain of the whole thing. Secondly, and of greater significance, this issue gives us a full blown X-Force vs. X-Factor/X-Men melee, with X-Force's eventual defeat more or less marking the official end of the first chapter of their existence: from this point forward, while the team will remain "extreme" in a relative (and vague) sense compared to the X-Men, the sort of over-the-top, teeth-gritting, flailingly-intense nonsense that characterized Liefeld's handful of issues, something from which Nicieza was already moving the series away prior to this issue, is more or less put to rest.

"X-Cutioner's Song" is, ultimately, an X-Force story: the other two teams get drawn in and play their part, but this is a story chiefly about the relationship between Cable & Stryfe, and between X-Force and the rest of the X-Men. The former has yet to unfold, but as act one closes, the latter is beginning to take shape, as X-Force, despite a valiant effort, falls short in the face of the X-Men and X-Factor. It's important that this happens in their own book, so as to make their defeat seem more legitimate (and not just a case of guest stars falling to the host title's characters), and Nicieza smartly both keeps the conflict from becoming a full-on route, and also establishing (over the previous few issues) that X-Force is hardly at their best; they've had one lucky escape after another, and now, their luck has simply run out. Thus, this isn't just the end of the first act of "X-Cutioner's Song", but really, the X-Force story that's been unfolding more or less since Liefeld left the series.

And with its end, X-Force will be allowed, subtly at first but eventually more overtly, to integrate more closely with the rest of the X-books. Which is another example of the larger changes wrought on the franchise by this story, the slight repudiation of the previous post-relaunch "Image" era of the central four books, which found most of them off doing their own thing, consciously ignoring much of the immediate past, each shepherded by a single artistic vision. "X-Cutioner's Song" doesn't succeed in all its objectives, but it does allow the series to interact more with their pasts, and with each other. A lot of the groundwork for that later achievement is laid here, with X-Force being taken off the board as the story's first act concludes.

Next Issue
Tomorrow, the X-Men (finally) guest star in Excalibur #57. Next week, the second act of "X-Cutioner's Song" begins in Uncanny X-Men #295 and X-Factor #85.

Collected Editions



  1. So...Stryfe's ridiculous helmet and shoulder-spikes AREN'T Liefeld's fault? Geez, twenty years of mockery wasted. :p No matter, still plenty to make fun of there.

    OMG Cable...'Overcompensation'. Have Graymalkin look it up. Thankfully IIRC he gets much better in his return from this crossover's finale.

    I was wondering what felt off about Silvestri's Sinister as opposed to the version we see from Kubert and Capullo. His lips aren't Hot Topic black, and he's missing his shark teeth. Honestly, it's an improvement.

  2. You should (probably) mention that this is the first time that Mr. Sinister seems to have an actual hair, instead of a "Colossus kind of metal hair" as before. See the picture you posted of him looking like a T-1000.

    BTW, Terminator 2 seems to have been a major influence in X-comics in this period. Certainly for Liefeld.

    1. Yeah, T2 was definitely a big influence on Liefeld. Then again, it was a huge movie at the time, and a big influence everywhere.

  3. At the end of part 3, Sinister said he was there to "bury" Xavier. In this issue, he tells them that he's there to reveal the name of the person behind the techno-virus that's killing Xavier, which presumably will allow the X-Men to save Xavier. So what was the point of Sinister's threat at the end of part 3, other than a dramatic ending?

    1. He was paraphrasing a popular quote from Shakespeare's Julius Caesar. But also he seems to get plenty of joy from Bishop's un-X-Men-like answer of just shooting him in the head. It was a test.

    2. Another example of the sloppy writing that makes me dislike this crossover.

    3. Eh, that strikes me less as sloppy writing than genre convention, not unlike an issue that ends with "OMG, Character X is dead!" and then by the first page of the next issue, he's fine.

      Also, of all the villains, it's certainly not out of character for Sinister to have a flair for dramatics. :)

  4. Is this the issue where Cannonball yells "X-Force, we are leeeeeaving!" or was that the last one? Either way, for some reason I've always chuckled at that line.

    I love that Mister Sinister greets the X-Men with not just a hologram -- but a fifty foot-tall hologram.

    "So, did Sinister and/or the MLF undress and dress them?"

    I kind of hope it was Sinister because at least he's a doctor. (Also, if you want to get really creepy about it, he technically knows what Jean -- and probably Cyclops too -- looks like naked so it's nothing new to him.)

    1. Yeah, this is the "leeeeaving" issue. I like it too.

    2. Or maybe they were just wearing their uniforms under their clothes ?
      I mean if Superman can hide a cape under his clothes.

    3. Not sure if it was a tribute, but Hicks in Aliens famously says, " Marines, we are leaving!!" When they are escaping said Aliens


  5. // Cable returns to his Swiss safe house, seen in his limited series, to gear up. //

    He must be using his TK power to keep all that ordnance from falling off him or dragging him down.

    // In perhaps the earliest bit of foreshadowing of the later Rictor/Shatterstar relationship //

    Today I learned…


Comment. Please. Love it? Hate it? Are mildly indifferent to it? Let us know!