Talking about comic books, TV shows, movies, sports, and the numerous other pastimes that make us Gentlemen of Leisure.

Thursday, October 11, 2018

X-amining X-Force #37

"The Young and the Restless"
August 1994

In a Nutshell
The Externals visit Cannonball at his family farm.

Writer: Fabian Nicieza
Guest Penciler: Paul Pelletier
Inkers: Harry Candelario, Scott Hanna, Charles Barnett
Guessed Letterer: Chris Eliopoulos
Gassed Colorist: Monica Bennet
Editor: Bob Harras
Editor-in-Chief: Tom DeFalco

Confronted by newfound mortality in the face of the Legacy Virus, the Externals seek out Cannonball at his family home. Nicodemus & Burke have died already, and Absalom is infected. Gideon tells Cannonball they've come to him because he represents hope. Meanwhile, at Campe Verde, Domino & Cable discuss a new base of operations for the team, while in the Bronx, Detective Hidalgo receives new information that may help him nail the Callasantos' sisters for the murder of their family. Back in Kentucky, Cannonball asks what the Externals want from him, and Absalom tells him Burke had a precognitive vision that Cannonball or someone close to him holds the key to curing the Legacy Virus. Just then, Absalom's power flares, one of the death knells of the virus, and Cannonball tells the Externals that when the time comes, he'll do whatever he can to help them. After they leave, Cannonball & Boomer declare their love for one another, then Cannonball says it's time to go back to Camp Verde to be with their friends and continue using whatever time they have left to make the world a better place.

Firsts and Other Notables
This issue reveals that not even the Externals are immune to the Legacy Virus, as it reveals that Nicodemus & Burke have both died of the illness (Nicodemus dies on-panel in issue #20; this issue makes it clear it was the Legacy Virus), and that Absalom is afflicted (complete with Revanche/Pyro-style lesions).

It also confirms that Apocalypse is one of the Externals, and encountered Saul in the 12th century. It also depicts his first encounter with Celestial technology, which claims for himself (though a later story makes it clear this isn't Ship).

It’s noted that Candra (the External who oversees the rivalry between the Thieves & Assassins Guilds) & Selene don’t attend regular External “Gatherings”.

The Externals claim that the precognitive Burke foresaw, before his death, that Cannonball (or someone close to him) would prove to be the key to curing the Legacy Virus; presumably, this is another reference to the “Cable is the key to curing the Legacy Virus” tease (which will ultimately prove to not be the case).

Cable & Domino are shown to be scouting new locations for X-Force’s base, with Cable saying the team has outgrown Camp Verde; in a few issues’ time, they’ll briefly move into the abandoned Murderworld.

In another subplot scene, we’re introduced to Detective Hidalgo, who is investigating the Callasantos
Sisters for the murder of their family; this is a reference to Feral & Thornn, and this subplot will become plot in issues #40-41.

Creator Central
This issue is drawn by Paul Pelletier, which surprised me only because I generally think of him as an artist who came around in the 00s. Apparently, I completely missed that he was working back in the early 90s. As an artist, he strikes me as being Tom Raney or Tom Grummett-esque, in that, his art isn't bad, but I'm never terribly excited to see it, because it usually shows up as a fill-in for the regular artist on a book.

The Chronology Corner
Cable appears here (and in the previous two issues) between issues #14 and #15 of his solo series.

A Work in Progress
Absalom refers to non-immortals as “Eyeblinks”.

Absalom tells the tale of how his mutant powers first manifested (and how he learned he was immortal), which involves him shooting Caleb Hammer in the back. Hammer is one of the more minor of Marvel’s various Old West characters, who first appeared in Marvel Premiere #54. He’ll also appear in the later “Blaze of Glory” miniseries that unites the assorted Old West characters in one tale.

Meanwhile, Gideon reveals that he was a deckhand on the Pinta who died of scurvy.

Gideon assigns a specific attribute to each of the Externals (though Apocalypse is left out), with Sam representing hope.

Young Love
In the wake of their encounter with the Externals (and a lot of high-minded talk of mortality), Sam & Boomer declare their love for each other.

Austin's Analysis
Fabian Nicieza has, over the course of his run as the sole writer on X-Force, done a lot to elevate the series from its Liefeldian beginnings, and, to his credit, he has done it without outwardly rejecting some of the more questionable elements from the series' earliest days. Unfortunately, that approach means, inevitably, he has to tackle the Externals (rather than just ignoring them), and while he already used them earlier in his run (in a way that read very much like an attempt to close that particular book), they return in this issue, as they attempt to reckon with their newly rediscovered mortality in the wake of the Legacy Virus. It's really the first time the group is being presented as something other than scheming, one-dimensional villains, as the threat of the Legacy Virus is used to shave off some of their rough edges. Nicieza is well aware of this (Boomer herself makes it clear to Gideon that they well remember what he did to Sunspot), but plunges forward nevertheless in an effort to make the most of the questionable "Cannonball is part of a secret cabal of immortal mutants!" storyline and give the Externals, collectively, if not individually, some depth.

For the most part, it works, at least in the context of this issue. I mean, no one is going to mourn for Absalom (or really even remember who he is) after this, but Nicieza manages to sell the central idea that this group of power-made schemers used to getting whatever they want is suddenly freaking the hell out because they've learned they're mortal again, and in desperation, they reach out to the one of them with the least incentive to help the rest. Even if we don't particularly care about the Externals, that's a decent premise on which to hang a story, and it works in large part because Sam never really buys what they're selling, with whatever salve he provides to them in the end coming not through any direct action on his part or a sudden acceptance of his role within the group, but just from them running up against his genuine good-heartedness.

The end result is, arguably, the best story involving the Externals which, admittedly, is clearing a very low bar. But kudos again to Nicieza for resisting the urge to just abandon these characters outright and instead squeezing out a tiny bit of lemonade from some very Liefeldian lemons. In the process, he suggests there could be more to the Externals than Gideon's pointlessly-convoluted machinations & the ridiculousness of Krule. There isn't, of course, but for an issue, at least, Nicieza sells the idea that such a thing is possible, which is no easy feat.

Next Issue
Tomorrow, the adventures of Zero conclude in Excalibur #80. Next week, the "Phalanx Covenant" finally begins, in Uncanny X-Men #316 and X-Factor #106.


  1. I mean, no one is going to mourn for Absalom

    You, sir, are a dick for writing this sentence. ;)

    1. A name like William Faulkner immortalized the poor guy in his novel. What's that? Oh, that wasn't about the character from X-Force? Well, my mistake.

    2. This seems a similar peccadillo to an old THOR issue where Odin punished Loki by imprisoning him into a tree, to be released only after even one person sheds a singular tear for him. So Loki controls the tree to drop a leaf on passing Heimdall which hits him in the eye and lo, there's the tear as ordered.

      I'll probably start weaving some devious scheme of my own centered on the fact that King David mourning for his son Absalom seems to be a big deal in the Bible. (Sam the old Sunday schooler maybe should have caught that intentional reference by the writer.)

  2. Gideon assigns a specific attribute to each of the Externals (though Apocalypse is left out), with Sam representing hope.

    So what trait is Crule? Ridiculousness?

    1. Ferocity, apparently. But I think he probably meant Ridiculousness.

    2. Paul Pelletier's early claim to fame was illustrating the Ex-Mutants for Malibu comics. His work was really nice, particularly the Pantheon back-ups he did on PAD's Incredible Hulk and it was a shame he didn't take over pencils on that title instead of Liam Sharp.

  3. Was it ever explained that the Externals were particularly prone to dying from the Legacy Virus? It had killed 2 of the already, and a third was sick already
    My first brush with Paul Pelletier was him filling in for Darryl Banks in Green Lantern. I thought he was out of the game but then he became Aquaman's penciller when Geoff Johns took it over

    1. I can't believe I'm suggesting a plot for the X-ternals, but honestly, being extra vulnerable to the Legacy Virus would have been an interesting hook. If they were just a bit more fleshed out, maybe that could have been a plot thread.

    2. If Apocalypse is supposed to be an X-Ternal now, it totally makes sense that Stryfe would have intentionally engineered the Legacy Virus to be especially infectious to his kind. Stryfe was supposed to be his inheritor, wasn't he?

      (... I'm in a bad place in life, if Stryfe and X-Ternals now start making sense to me.)

  4. Just curious: was there some editorial mandate that logistical/expository discussions between Cable and Domino were best visualized while bathing?

  5. I didn't know Paul Pelletier was working in the 90s, either. I think the first time I encountered him was as a semi-regular fill-in artist on Dan Slott's SHE-HULK, and I thought he was a way better fit for the character than the series' regular artist, Juan Bobillo.

    There are certain guys, such as Pelletier and Tom Grummett, who you mentioned above, where I'm astounded that they never became bigger deals. I mean, yeah, Grummett was pretty high profile at DC on the Superman titles, but I think he's such a great artist that I feel he should be mentioned alongside guys like Byrne and Davis -- which, obviously, he isn't. And speaking of Davis, that's partly who Pelletier's artwork has always reminded me of.

    I always preface stuff like this next paragraph by noting that there's no accounting for taste, but -- I did a post on my blog a while back about my five favorite superhero comic artists, kind of limiting that to guys who did most or all of their output during my lifetime, and I came up with John Byrne, Alan Davis, Mark Bagley, Tom Grummett, and George Perez. If Pelletier had ever had something like a long run on AVENGERS or a similar title, he'd probably bump Perez off the list for me.

    (Which isn't to say I don't like Perez quite a bit -- but those other four all have a certain sort of similarity in their styles which I can't quite articulate, which I think Pelletier would fit perfectly alongside -- while Perez, to me, sticks out among the group as different somehow.)

    So anyway, I really like Paul Pelletier's artwork.

    1. In case you’re not aware, Matt, and for the benefit of other Grummett fans, I want to plug the long-awaited completion of Section Zero, the series he created with inker/writer Karl Kesel for the short-lived Gorilla imprint almost 20 years ago now. I’m choosy about Kickstarters but I happily backed this one, which thanks to stretch goals being met resulted in a handsome “Ultra-Cool Collector’s Edition” hardcover; you can get the book for $40 postpaid and/or the digital edition for $12 at the Panic-Button Press website. It’s fun stuff that anyone who’s enjoyed their work together, most of all the Challengers of the Fantastic Amalgam one-shot, should love and I hope they get to do more.

  6. I’m not sure whether it’s due more to the generation gap or DC vs. Marvel leanings — I have 8-10 years on at least Matt & Austin; other regulars here, apart from Jack, seem to be roughly their age — but I became aware of Pelletier on the Outsiders series from this era. To my eyes he did good, solid work that wasn’t anything special on the order of Byrne, PĂ©rez, or Davis (nor Chris Bachalo, Mike Wieringo, or Carlos Pacheco, to include pencilers of Pelletier’s vintage, let alone your less conventional artists like Sienkiewicz or Mignola) but got bumped up an entire class given the styles — and lack of foundational ability of most of the stylists — taking over the industry.


Comment. Please. Love it? Hate it? Are mildly indifferent to it? Let us know!