Three guys talking about comic books, sports, movies, TV shows and the numerous other pastimes that make us Gentlemen of Leisure.

Saturday, July 2, 2016

Force in Focus: Star Wars #39

"The Empire Strikes Back"
September 1980

In a Nutshell
An Imperial Probe discovers the location of the Rebel's new base on Hoth.

Writer/Editor: Archie Goodwin
Artists: Al Williamson & Carlos Garzon
Colorist: Glynis Wein
Letterer: Jim Novak
Assistant Editor: Jo Duffy
Editor-in-Chief: James Shooter

Plot
Patrolling on the ice world of Hoth, Luke is about to investigate a nearby meteorite when he's attacked by some kind of creature. Later, Han returns to the Rebel's Echo Base having finished his own patrol, and announces his intent to leave the Rebellion to square his debt with Jabba the Hutt. Elsewhere, Luke awakens upside down inside a cave, and uses the Force to call his lightsaber to his hand, freeing himself and fighting off the creature before fleeing into the freezing night. At Echo Base, Han learns Luke is missing and races off into the night to find him, while Luke is visited by the spirit of Obi-Wan Kenobi, who advises him to go to Dagobah, to learn the ways of the Force from Yoda. Just then, Han comes across the nearly dead Luke, and erects shelter. The next morning, however, a patrol Snowspeeders tracks down Han and Luke, and after a trip to the bacta tank, Luke is pronounced out of danger. Just then, the same creatures which attacked him attack the base. At the same time, their scanners detect the presence of an Imperial Probe Droid - the meteorite Luke spotted earlier. Han and Chewbacca manage to destroy it, but not before it transmits its data to the Imperial fleet. The data is received by Darth Vader's massive new Star Destroyer, and though his officers aren't sure if the data points to Rebel activity, Vader is certain, and orders the fleet to the Hoth system at full speed.

Firsts and Other Notables
This issue begins the series' adaptation of The Empire Strikes Back, which will run for six issues (as with the adaptation of the original film), concluding with issue #44. Unlike the adaptation of A New Hope, which began before the film was released and was intended to help drum up buzz about the movie, this issue wasn't on sale until late June of 1980, over a month after the film was released into theaters, in order to protect the film's secrets (and because by 1980, Star Wars was a cultural phenomenon, Empire a highly-anticipated sequel that needed no help generating buzz).

A bunch of new stuff is, not surprisingly, introduced this issue: new, Hoth-based looks for Luke, Han and Leia, a new long-sleeved jacket for Han (mostly replacing his vest), the planet Hoth, Rebel officers Derlin and Rieekan (both unnamed), Imperial Captain Piett (unnamed) and Admiral Ozzel, as well as General Veers (mentioned but not seen), the creatures tauntauns and wampas, Imperial Probe droids, as well as the Rebel's Snowspeeders and the massive Super Star Destroyer, Darth Vader's flagship, which eclipses the previous Star Destroyers in size.

The issue opens with a splash page that almost functions as a second cover, showing the heroes posed in their Hoth gear, with Vader looming large behind them. The second page then features a variation on the opening crawl of the film, with Luke astride his tauntaun in one corner, leading into the full action on the third page.


The cover to this issue, somewhat unfortunately, is the first of the series to feature one of the infamous yellow banner ads that muddy up the top third of numerous Marvel Comics covers around this time, including the seminal conclusion to the "Dark Phoenix Saga" over in X-Men (which was on sale at the same time as this issue).

Creator Central 
Al Williamson & Carlos Garzon take over as the series' penciler & inker for the duration of the adaptation; previous regular artist Carmine Infantino will return with issue #45. A letter from the editor on the letters page speaks briefly about the adaptation process, and also explains how Williamson & Garzon don't work in the traditional penciler/inker tandem (with the two swapping roles sometimes from page to page, or even panel to panel).


Jo Duffy, who will eventually write for this series, is credited this issue as an assistant editor on the book.

A Work in Progress
Since last issue and this one, the Rebels have relocated from their base on Yavin Four to one on the ice world of Hoth, dubbed Echo Base, which is still being setup, their equipment adapted to the cold, as the story begins.

Han's motivation to leave the Rebels at the start of the issue is prompted by an encounter with a bounty hunter on Ord Mantell, an event which has been chronicled a few different ways through the years. It also doesn't quite gel with the ending of the previous issue, which found Han motivated to return to the Rebels due to the resumption of the price on his head.

Luke's successful retrieval of it represents the first time we've really seen the Force used for telekinesis.


Um, Actually
As with Thomas & Chaykin in the adaptation of A New Hope, Goodwin and company were working off an earlier draft of Empire's screenplay than what ended up being film when crafting these issues, and a result a number of differences between the comic and the finished film exist. First and foremost, the opening crawl in this issue is different than that of the film (I believe the crawls are usually written very close to when the finished film is sent off to theaters, and thus, Goodwin would have no idea what is was when writing this issue).


Something I never noticed before re-reading this issue now: Luke first appears watching a meteorite falling to the ground through his macrobinoculars, which might have been an attempt to echo the his intended first appearance in earlier drafts of A New Hope, in which he is first seen watching the space battle above Tatooine through his binoculars before rushing off to tell his friends in the Anchorhead deleted scene.

As such, where the film opens with shots of the probe droids being launched from Star Destroyers (presumably to echo the opening post-crawl shot of a looming Star Destroyer in the first film) and following one of them to Hoth, and Luke, here, the issue opens with Luke on Hoth, spotting the crashed droid in the distance (though this may have been a deliberate change made by Goodwin, to add to the impact of the Empire's arrival for the issue-ending cliffhanger.

Here, Han's discussion with leaving the Rebellion due to the price on his head, and being told a death mark is not an easy thing to live with, occurs between him and, presumably, Major Derlin (the unnamed-in-the-film Rebel officer somewhat famously played by John Ratzenberger aka Cliff Clavin), rather than with General Rieekan, as in the movie.


Han and Leia's subsequent argument is different than what appears in the film, much more inline with deleted scenes that appeared on the saga's Blu-ray release and thus, another reminder that Goodwin is working off an earlier draft of the script.


Unlike in the movie, Luke is motivated to use the Force to retrieve his lightsaber in the wampa cave by Obi-Wan's voice. His lightsaber is also referred to as a "lightblade" in this scene.


One of the big deleted scenes from Empire, on par with the Anchorhead/Biggs material from the first film, is the wampa attack on Echo Base, a series of segments in the opening act that found wampas attacking the Rebels, getting corralled into holding cell, and then Threepio helping unleash the wampas on unsuspecting Imperials during their attack on the base (the only thing which remains of the sequence in the finished film is the brief shot of snow falling on Artoo's head as he rolls down a corridor). In this issue, we briefly see the wampas attack inside the base, and Leia orders the surrounding caves to be scanned for more of them.


However, we never actually see the wampas, either in the base or the one that attacks Luke, presumably because Goodwin & Williamson weren't given any reference material for them by LucasFilm, nor are they referred to as wampas in the issue.

When Han rescues Luke, the sequence of him using Luke's lightsaber to cut open the dead tauntaun and stuff Luke inside (a scene which comprises one of my earliest film memories) is omitted.

The attack on the probe droid is more complicated here than in the movie; it first destroys a Rebel outpost, a snowspeeder is shown investigating it, and Chewbacca is used more deliberately as a decoy to lure it out in the open, where Han shoots its.


The Space-Lexicon
Attacked by a wampa, Luke declares "Son of a jumpin'" but is cut off before we find out what was jumping.

Han lists "gank killers" amongst the things Jabba is sending after him.

Austin's Analysis
One of the things I've always loved about Marvel's adaptation of Empire is that they did it as part of the ongoing series (rather than breaking it out as its own limited series, as they do with the Return of the Jedi adaptation). Reading it now, as part of a survey of the entire series, I appreciate it even more, as it helps make the events of the film read more like the continuation of the adventures of the main characters and of the series' overall narrative, as it should. But it does raise an unfortunate problem with the art. Al Williamson & Carlos Garzon's work is great: being more photorealistic it's certainly appropriate for the adaptation of the film (Luke, Han and Leia have never looked more like their movie counterparts in this series than this issue), and they certainly has the chops for Star Wars, as seen in the newspaper comic strip. But it still bugs me that they take over the series, just for the length of the adaptation, from Carmine Infantino.

Infantino is the book's regular artist, with more issues of the series under his belt than anyone else, and not only would it have been fun to see his more angular, traditionally comic book-y style interpret the events of the film, it also would have helped add to that feeling that Empire is just the latest adventure for the characters, the next story in the series. Had Infantino's run ended prior to the adaptation, the presence of Williamson & Garzon might feel different, but he'll return once Empire is done for a handful of issues more, reinforcing the unfortunate notion that he's good enough for the series, but not good enough for the high profile adaptation of the film sequel. Which is unfortunate, because it takes away from the effect elevated by having the story run as part of the regular, ongoing series. Williamson & Garzon's work is great, and I generally enjoy it here on its own merits, but it's still a shame that Infantino, the book's regular artist, wasn't allowed to continue the strong work he'd been doing, especially given the higher profile of this story.

Next Issue
The Empire fulfills its titular obligations on Hoth.

Collected Editions 

6 comments:

  1. The adaptation also adds a scene of Luke receiving facial surgery.

    ReplyDelete
  2. IMO, the most beautiful Star Wars artwork until Marvel gets the license back. Along with the monthly adaptation, I've also got a beaten-up Treasury Edition of ESB; IIRC some errors in it are corrected in the floppies (Yoda is originally mis-colored) as the Treasury was probably released concurrent with the movie. Looks great at actual size.

    ReplyDelete

  3. // the infamous yellow banner ads that muddy up the top third of numerous Marvel Comics covers around this time //

    I hated them so much. So much.

    // Luke first appears watching a meteorite falling to the ground through his macrobinoculars //

    Or as we 20th- and 21st-century Earth people might know them: “binoculars”!

    // Infantino is the book's regular artist, with more issues of the series under his belt than anyone else, and … it also would have helped add to that feeling that Empire is just the latest adventure for the characters, the next story in the series //

    I’m really sympathetic towards this, especially when you put that last part the way you did. Yet to both support and refute your point, Williamson & Garzon’s style and heavy usage of photo-reference pretty definitively says to me that this is the real stuff, and I didn’t even realize how glad I’d be to see the change; given how Infantino’s designs for characters new to the series have been so reminiscent of his Silver Age sci-fi work at DC, full of skintight costumes and heroic physiques and bold swatches of single color, one could hardly get a starker contrast within the same genre. I guess the ideal scenario would’ve been to let Infantino adapt the movie’s events for the monthly series while running Williamson & Garzon’s version as a special, separate Empire mini or standalone treasury edition, but although I could see that happening today, in the way there’s an audience for manga-style adaptations of the films, it certainly wasn’t going to happen back then. I find a lot to enjoy in what Infantino’s been doing but it never feels like Star Wars to me, so I’m happy to see Williamson & Garzon’s more illustrative, photo-reference-laden approach. The only problem is that the stories drawn in Infantino’s style are going to seem even less canonical going forward, both for coming on the heels of this switch and because now, with the release of Empire truly making Star Wars an ongoing film series, it can’t help but be more apparent that the monthly comics are merely incidental riffs on the actual saga.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Shout-out to Glynis Wein/Oliver, by the way. Just look at all that white, those secondary colors and pastels — everything’s blue, orange, purple, green, brown, yellow, pink; there are just one or two spots of red in the whole issue. I have a few quibbles about how a few pages don’t come together as a whole, but overall it’s just masterful stuff, particularly given (but also, in large part, made possible/necessary by) technical limitations of the era, whose flat rendering and moody, as opposed to literal, interpretation is to my eyes vastly preferable to the sort of modern recolored work you wrote about here last year.

      Delete
  4. The cover to this issue, somewhat unfortunately, is the first of the series to feature one of the infamous yellow banner ads that muddy up the top third of numerous Marvel Comics covers around this time, including the seminal conclusion to the "Dark Phoenix Saga" over in X-Men (which was on sale at the same time as this issue).

    A lot has been said of UXM #137 missing the Comics Code stamp, which has been officially attributed to the yellow banner hogging up the space for it and having nothing to do with Jean Grey committing a suicide in the issue. They point you to CAPTAIN AMERICA #249 of the same cover month also with the banner and also missing the CC stamp. Except, the said CAP issue also has a villain committing willing suicide by Captain, whereas here they seem to have had little problem finding the space for the stamp telling that the contents abide to the Comics Code. The ASM #208 of the same month and banner has the stamp, too. FF #222 has both, so does AVENGERS #199.

    Shenanigans, I tell you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I hadn't thought about the implications of Carmine Infantino skipping EMPIRE, but then I guess I just kind of figured there was some sort of deadline thing involved, rather than any attempt to snub him (conscious or not).

    Nonetheless, I love this artwork. Al Williamson was born to draw Star Wars -- though I find I like him on almost everything. I have those old Dark Horse trades of the SW newspaper strip I've mentioned before, and I recently picked up the relatively recent collections of the SECRET AGENT CORRIGAN strip Goodwin mentions in the column you posted. I would love to get hold of his FLASH GORDON material as well. Apparently there was a collection of it a few years back, but it seems to be out of print and expensive.

    It occurs to me -- I wonder if any of these Marvel comics actually were worth $2,500 to anybody?

    ReplyDelete

Comment. Please. Love it? Hate it? Am mildly indifferent to it? Let us know!