Talking about comic books, TV shows, movies, sports, and the numerous other pastimes that make us Gentlemen of Leisure.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Retro Review: Treehouse of Horror II

Or the One Where: Lisa's nightmare (a wish-granting Monkey's Paw leads to alien domination), Bart's nightmare (Bart is an omnipotent being who grows to love his father) and Homer's nightmare (his brain is transplanted into a worker robot by Mr. Burns).

The Setup: Following trick-or-treating, Lisa, Bart and Homer all gorge on candy, which gives them all nightmares.

 Notable Notes: Marge once again warns the audience about the content of the show before it begins.

The "scary names" tradition, in which the names in the credits of the Halloween episodes are altered to scary or humorous effect, begins with this episode.

Favorite Lines
Lisa: I wish for world peace.
Homer: Lisa, that was very selfish of you!

Homer: I wish for a turkey sandwich on rye bread with lettuce and mustard. And-and I don't want any zombie turkeys, I don't want to turn into a Turkey myself, and I don't want any other weird surprises-you got it?

Kang: It seems the earthlings won.  
Kodos: Did they? That board with a nail in it may have defeated us. But the humans won't stop there. They'll make bigger boards and bigger nails, and soon, they will make a board with a nail so big, it will destroy them all!

Marge: Goodness, what's wrong?
Bart: We both had nightmares.
Lisa: Can we sleep with you?
Homer: You both toilet trained?
Bart and Lisa: Yes!

Burns: Smithers, hand me that ice-cream scoop.
Smithers: Ice-cream scoop?!
Burns: Dammit, Smithers, this isn't rocket science, it's brain surgery!

Teebore's Take: A solid improvement over the first Halloween outing, this episode draws inspiration from short fiction (W.W Jacobs The Monkey's Paw), The Twilight Zone and Frankenstein. While there are individual segments from other Treehouse episodes I enjoy more, all three of these stories are very good, with equal parts humor and Halloween-ness. The Monkey's Paw segment, teaching us the danger of simplistic wishing and culminating in Homer's wish-granted turkey sandwich being a little dry, is a Simpsons classic in its own right, and easily my favorite of the three (though Mr. Burns' turn as a mad scientist is close behind it).


Both a classic Halloween episode and an overall classic.


The framing sequence of trick-or-treat candy inspired nightmares and the general creepiness and unreality of all three stories help make this episode feel suitably Halloween-y.


  1. this is indeed one of the best halloween episodes. And i agree that monkey paw is the best of the shorts in the episode.

    I've always been very conscious, even as a child, that it's important to wish specifically

  2. What Sarah said

    I remember we would always watch the Halloween episodes of Simpsons on Halloween (when we were too old to trick or treat). Then they moved the season back


  3. @Falen: I've always been very conscious, even as a child, that it's important to wish specifically

    And always wish for more wishes, if they'll let you.

    @Anne: Then they moved the season back

    Yeah, it was pretty bad for awhile there. They've gotten better about it recently, but now, the Halloween episode aren't very Halloween-y anyway.

    I never understood why Fox didn't just run the new Halloween episode on Halloween, whatever day of the week it was, and then again on the nearest Sunday.

  4. I don't think I've seen this one at all. WTH? I gotta start netflixing these in all seriousness.

  5. @Palindrome: Yeah, get on that, posthaste! You can always borrow them from me too, if you'd like.


Comment. Please. Love it? Hate it? Are mildly indifferent to it? Let us know!